Shootouts

Sony Ericsson Satio & Samsung Pixon12 - 12-Megapixel Takeover!

By Seow Tein Hee - 30 Oct 2009

Conclusion

Closing Shots

The facts are these: megapixel numbers aren't the most indicative measure of how good a camera is. While both the Satio and Pixon12 have attained a similar imaging resolution to the more recent compact cameras, it will not be a true replacement to what you get with dedicated compact camera. Each of the device has shown that it is capable of faster speeds in both focusing and image processing, and gave us decent images in both resolution and image quality when considering its camera phone segment. Noise levels will still be the predominant issue, but unavoidable due to the smaller sensor size needed to be packed within a compact mobile phone's frame.

Now, on a side-by-side comparison between these two 12-megapixel camera phones, the question is - which one would you go for? When it comes to colors, it really depends on your choice and taste. The Pixon12 would definitely return warmer and vivid colors, but within brighter conditions, the colors could be too rich for one's taste. If details and resolution gets your attention, the Satio stands a better chance at winning your heart. Noise levels are a tie between these two devices. Looking at the sample images, you might have noticed that the Pixon12's wide-angle lens is great for large groups, but self-portraits will be an issue with barrel distortion coming into the equation.

Nonetheless, factor in the considerations of having a truly converged device with above average imaging quality, and these two devices will be the top of the pack amongst its peers. The Satio does have an edge when it comes to its usability with a large 3.5-inch screen. The tradeoff is in the overly large body that is required to house the screen and camera sensor. And yes, don't get us started on the lens cover which gave the Satio its odd shape. While we do prefer the Pixon12 for its more compact nature, there are also a few misgivings such as the lack of a 3.5mm audio jack (this applies to the Satio too). And even though the fingerprint smudges are relatively less than what you see on the Satio, it also irked us over the glossy nature of such mobile devices.

Sony Ericsson Satio, or Samsung Pixon12? For us, we found both devices to be equally capable when it comes to imaging. But if it boils down to the full package, the Pixon12 will have the advantage with its greater mileage and more compact build.

The Pixon12's greatest advantage over the Satio lies with its AMOLED display for power efficiency and greater screen clarity with higher resolution, even though the screen size measures in at a smaller 3.1 inches. And speaking of power efficiency, it's apparent that if you value portability, the Pixon12 would be the perfect choice with its longer battery uptime and a more compact body. And, if you're still torn about your decision, perhaps the S$998 price tag of the Pixon12 (without contract) might sweeten deal against the Satio's more expensive S$1098 asking price. In any case, here's a quick summary of the Satio's and Pixon12's pros and cons to aid your decision making:-.

Final Ratings

Samsung Pixon12

Pros
  • AMOLED display
  • Fast autofocus speeds, slightly more than 1 second.
  • Compact
  • High mileage
Cons
  • Slow image processing speeds, up to 4 seconds.
  • Colors that could be too rich under brighter conditions.

Sony Ericsson Satio

Pros
  • Large 3.5-inch screen for movie viewing and web browsing
  • Fast image processing speeds, less than 1 second.
  • Sharper details on images
  • Fares better than the Pixon12 in low lighting conditions.
Cons
  • Slow autofocus, up to nearly 3 seconds.
  • Bulky
  • Lower usability for interface
 

 

Join HWZ's Telegram channel here and catch all the latest tech news!
Our articles may contain affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a small commission.